Skip to main content

Jamie Benn deserves the Hart Trophy

On a hot streak when his Stars need it most, captain Jamie Benn would be a worthy winner of the 2016 Hart Trophy.

Get all of Allan Muir’s columns as soon as they’re published. Download the new Sports Illustrated app (iOS or Android) and personalize your experience by following your favorite teams and SI writers.

Braden Holtby is on the verge of setting a single-season record for wins by a goaltender. Patrick Kane is about to become the first American-born player ever to win a scoring title. And Sidney Crosby has recovered from the worst start of his career to lift the Evgeni Malkin-less Penguins to unexpected heights.

When voting for the Hart Trophy kicks off next week, all three players deserve serious consideration to be honored as the NHL's most valuable player. But as the season races toward the finish, I'm leaning towards another candidate: Dallas Stars captain Jamie Benn.

The 26-year-old forward has been in the mix from the start, scoring in nine of his first 10 games to build upon his remarkable 2015 scoring title. But he's made himself a more obvious choice as the playoff races have tightened up and the games have taken on a greater sense of urgency.

The Crosby Conundrum: Entering middle age, who is Sid the Kid?

​Benn reached the 40-goal plateau for the first time in his career with a second-period tally in the Stars’ 4–1 win over the Coyotes on Thursday night. He now ranks second in the NHL in goals behind Washington's Alex Ovechkin (44) and is the first 40-goal scorer for the Stars since Mike Modano had 50 in 1993-94. He also picked up an assist on Patrick Sharp's clincher, giving him 87 points on the season. That equals his career high set last year and moves him to within seven points of Kane in his bid to repeat as the league's top scorer.

That particular goal might seem like a bridge too far, but don't rule him out. Playing his best hockey of the season, Benn has points in 10 of his past 12 contests (8-8-16), with multiple-point efforts in six of his past 10.

It's no surprise to see him elevate his game this time of year. The Stars are in a dogfight with the Blues to seize top spot in the Central and Benn is a player who is at his absolute best in the clutch.

He showed that last season when he hunted down Crosby and John Tavares of the Islanders for the Art Ross, torching opponents for 16 points in Dallas' last seven games, including four in the finale, to claim the scoring title. He showed it in Sochi, when he tallied the only goal in Canada's 1–0 Olympic semifinal win over Team USA.

And now he's doing it again.

"He's the one guy you always look at and wonder what might have been," an NHL exec recently said of Benn, who slid all the way to the fifth round of the 2007 draft. "He makes a difference every night. There are no shortcuts in his game.

"There's a lot of talent on that team, but he's the straw that stirs the drink."

Ducks, Stars, Blues facing crucial goaltending decisions

​Benn sets the tone for his team with every aspect of his play. He's a show-not-tell type of captain. When the Stars needs a jolt, he ramps up his physical play (team-leading 146 hits). When a message needs to be sent, he'll drop the gloves. (He's fought St. Louis captain David Backes twice in the past year, winning both times according to He handles tougher defensive responsibilities than either Kane or Crosby.

And he's been a remarkably consistent producer, scoring in 54 of Dallas's 78 games. Benn's longest scoreless stretch was four games, from Jan. 2-7, and that was one of just four times all season in which he was held without a point in consecutive games.

“He can do it with skill and he can do it with power," Dallas coach Lindy Ruff said after Thursday night's win. "He has a great shot. He gets around the net and gets tips and rebounds. I think the reason he scored that many is he scores goals many different ways. Some goal scorers have a favorite spot or stay in one area on the power play. He moves around quite a bit and scores a lot of different types of goals for us.”

And he's doing it all when his team needs him most. The Stars took a big hit earlier this month when Tyler Seguin, then the NHL's third-leading scorer, was lost for the regular season with a torn Achilles tendon. It was an injury that easily could have hobbled Dallas' offense and derailed the team's bid for a division title. Instead, Benn has ramped up his game to meet the challenge. Compare that response to the recent play of Kane, who has one goal and five points over his past 10 games as Chicago's season slowly unravels.

It's great for the league that there are so many viable candidates for its top individual prize. But by playing his best hockey when the games mean the most, Benn is proving himself as the cream of the crop.

The SI Extra Newsletter Get the best of Sports Illustrated delivered right to your inbox


The numbers game

• The Panthers (43 wins) and Kings (46) need one more to break their respective franchise records for victories in a season. Florida's was set in 1999-2000, Los Angeles's in 2013-14.​

• Golden Geezer Jagr Stat o' the Day: Jaromir has now scored at least 60 points in a season for the 18th time in his career. Only two players Gordie Howe (21) and Wayne Gretzky (19) have done it more often.

• If the Red Wings or Bruins lose on Friday night, you can look forward to seeing Sidney Crosby and the Penguins in the playoffs.

•​ If you have been, are now or one day will be a hockey parent, this oral history of life in and around the rinks is a must-read.

• It's time for Bruins president Cam Neely to make his intentions known regarding the future of coach Claude Julien.

NHL goalies trying to get equipment rules changes right

• Here's an oral history of the greatest hockey game ever played. Wish I could have seen this one myself.

• The head of the NHL Alumni Association attended player concussion lawsuit meetings and then shared intel with the NHL. Yes, that's exactly as sorry as it sounds.

• Here's the story of how the Portland Rosebuds became the first American team to have their names engraved on the Stanley Cup ... despite not really winning it. I'll tell you, Moose Johnson sounds like the toughest man who ever lived.

• Is this the end of the Mario Lemieux era in Pittsburgh? Rumors are circulating that No. 66 is on the verge of selling the Penguins.

• You won't believe all the cool stuff this hardcore Maple Leafs collector has accumulated.

• Apparently, pessimism runs deep among Nashville Predators fans.

• Jack Eichel, William Nylander and Sonny Milano, all on the same team? Not a bad bunch of pee wees.