1 of 18

You wrote. We listened. Here's a sampling of your comments and nominations in reaction to our best baseball players by number feature.

In a powered-up offensive era (especially powered-up when considering middle infield), Jeter has slugged .461, compared to Gehringer 's .480. Gehringer's on-base percentage was .404, compared to Jeter's .388. Jeter was never even MVP, which Gehringer was. And let's see where the already declining Jeter's numbers are after another five years.
-DJ Sparks

Photo: Charles M. Conlon/TSN/Icon SMI

Average: 5 (1 vote)