3 of 10

As a three-year-old, Conley was a huge fan of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, but his favorite thing about Halloween was the candy. "He had a huge sweet tooth and would come home and rummage through all the treats he received," says his father, Mike Sr. "The next morning, his mom would find remnants of candy wrappers everywhere: under his bed, under his blankets, and under his pillows."

Text: Sachin Shenolikar
Photo: COURTESY OF THE CONLEY FAMILY, ROBERT BECK/SPORTS ILLUSTRATED

Average: 2.6 (9 votes)